

Design and Construct or Construct Only: How the Risk Actually Shifts
Under construct only, the design is the principal’s problem. Under design and construct, it becomes yours, including the parts someone else drew before you were engaged. Here is where each risk actually lands.
The design review on a Parramatta mid-rise is in its fourth week when the architect issues revision F of the façade sections. The window frames are now thermally broken, the head details are deeper, and the glazing subcontractor’s price has moved by $186,000.
The architect used to work for the developer. Since novation in March, the architect works for the builder. The developer’s project manager calls the revision design development. The builder’s commercial manager calls it a variation. Both have the design and construct contract open on the table, and both think it supports them.
What is a design and construct contract?
A design and construct contract, or D&C contract, makes the contractor responsible for both designing and building the works. The principal states what it wants, usually in the Principal’s Project Requirements or a design brief, and the contractor develops the design, documents it and builds it, commonly for a lump sum.
How much design the principal hands over varies. AS 4902, the Australian Standard design and construct form, is used for straight design and construct, for design development and construct, and for design, novate and construct.[1] In the last two, the principal’s consultants take the design part of the way before the builder arrives.
What stays constant is the risk. Once the contract is D&C, the adequacy of the design is presumed to be the contractor’s problem, including parts it did not draw, unless the contract expressly gives relief for the principal’s own design.
What is a construct only contract?
A construct only contract is the traditional model. The principal’s designers produce the design and the contractor builds what the drawings show. Under an unmodified AS 4000, the principal is liable for defects in the design it provides, although the contractor has an implied duty to warn of design defects it notices.[1]
That split is less clean than it looks. Principals often add buildability clauses, which can impose fitness for purpose obligations without using the words.[3]
Which Australian standard forms are D&C and which are construct only?
Form | Model | Design responsibility | Status |
|---|---|---|---|
AS 2124-1992 | Construct only | Principal designs; contractor builds to the documents[3] | Predecessor construct only form |
AS 4000-1997 and AS 4000:2025 | Construct only | Principal designs; contractor must warn of errors it notices. Standards Australia says the 2025 edition keeps the 1997 risk allocation[1][2] | AS 4000:2025 published June 2025[2] |
AS 4902-2000 | Design and construct | Contractor completes the design and warrants the works fit for their stated purpose[3] | Still the 2000 edition; to be revised to align with AS 4000:2025[2] |
GC21 Edition 2 | Configurable | Contractor completes the principal’s design at minimum; the Contract Information lists what it develops or fully designs[4] | NSW Government form; the ACT publishes a modified version |
GC21 is often described as construct only. It is not. Clause 39.1 requires the contractor to complete the principal’s design and carry out all other design needed for the works.[4] One commentator’s conclusion is that any contractor using GC21 must recognise it as a design and construct contract.[1] Clause numbers here are from the ACT-modified GC21 Edition 2; check them against the version in your contract.
For the wider menu of lump sum, cost plus and schedule of rates arrangements, see our guide to types of construction contracts.
Fitness for purpose or reasonable skill and care?
This is the biggest shift between the two models, and it hides in a short warranty clause.
Reasonable skill and care is the ordinary standard for a professional designer. An engineer must design as a competent engineer would, but does not guarantee the result.[3]
Fitness for purpose is a promise about the outcome. If the works do not do what they were meant to do, the contractor is in breach even if everyone was careful. The principal only has to prove the result was not achieved, which is far easier than proving negligence.[3]
AS 4902 clause 2.2 has the contractor warrant that the completed works will be fit for their stated purpose. A common amendment replaces “stated” with “intended”, stretching the warranty to purposes the contract never wrote down. Courts also imply fitness for purpose readily into D&C contracts, and much less readily into construct only forms.[3] GC21 clause 39.2 sets the same standard: the works must be “fit for the purposes required by the Contract”.[4]
1 word
Changing ’stated’ to ’intended’ in AS 4902 clause 2.2 extends the fitness for purpose warranty to purposes the contract never wrote down.
Vincent Young, Fitness for purpose warranties (2022)
What does novation do to the design team?
Novation is the hand-over in the opening scene. The principal engages the architect and engineers, takes the design to a point, then transfers their appointments to the builder by deed.
Who the consultants answer to. Before novation, the principal’s consultants owe their duties to the principal, and courts are reluctant to find a separate duty to the contractor where the contracts allocate risk in detail. After novation, under a typical novation deed, the consultant is directly accountable to the contractor, including for errors made before the contractor arrived.[5] The builder inherits every assumption the design team made while working for someone else.
“Design liability under a design & construct contract stays with the contractor regardless of who prepares the drawings.”
Vincent Young, Always presume design liability (2023)[5]
What the consultants actually do. Novation does not automatically shrink a consultant’s role, but consultants can easily assume it does. The ACA also warns that novation can silo consultants so that specialist advice goes missing, noting that in both Lacrosse and Grenfell Tower it appears the fire engineer did not review or advise on completed design documents.[6]
Timing matters as much as the deed. Novation can happen at 5% of design documentation or at 95%.[6] The earlier it happens, the more design the builder has to finish, and the more of the eventual cost is design development rather than variation.
5% or 95%
Novation could take place at 5% completion of design documentation, or at 95%.
Association of Consulting Architects Australia (2022)
Design development or variation?
This is the most common fight on a D&C job, and it is the one in the Parramatta meeting room.
Design development is the work of turning the brief or a preliminary design into a buildable, compliant set of documents. Under D&C, the contractor was paid to do it. GC21 clause 39.4 says that, subject to the clause on proposed departures, “design or design development does not cause a Variation or reduce the Contractor’s design responsibilities”.[4]
A variation is a change to what the principal asked for: new scope, a changed brief, a different finish from the one the requirements name.
The practical test is one question. Was this change needed to deliver what the requirements already asked for, or does it change what they asked for?
Here is the Parramatta job worked through. Assumptions: a $28 million D&C contract, novated at design development stage, a 1.5% design contingency in the tender price, and a 10% margin on variations under the contract.
Change | Why it arose | Classification | Cost |
|---|---|---|---|
Thermally broken façade frames | Needed to meet the energy performance the requirements specified | Design development | $186,000 |
Thicker level 3 transfer slab | Needed to carry the loads the requirements specified | Design development | $98,000 |
Rooftop pergola | Added by the developer after a marketing review | Variation | $142,000 |
Stone bathroom tiles | Developer changed the finish the requirements named | Variation | $64,000 |
The two design development items total $284,000 and sit in the builder’s price. The contingency was 1.5% of $28 million, or $420,000, so it absorbs them with $136,000 to spare. The two variations total $206,000; with the 10% margin the builder claims $226,600.
Now take the same job tendered with no contingency, at a 4% margin of $1.12 million. The $284,000 comes straight out of margin, about a quarter of it, and the builder is tempted to claim the façade as a variation. Most of these disputes start with a tender that never priced the design it was taking on.
Real briefs are rarely this tidy, which is why every revision needs a record of the requirement it answers to. Where the argument goes otherwise is covered in how construction variations turn into disputes.
$284,000
Design development on a $28 million D&C job that no variation will recover. Priced in a 1.5% contingency, it is absorbed. Left out, it takes a quarter of a 4% margin.
Worked example
Who owns design risk when the brief is incomplete?
Under D&C, mostly the contractor. An incomplete brief is the normal state of a D&C tender, and the fitness for purpose warranty fills the gaps with whatever the works need to meet their stated purpose (or intended purpose, if the clause has been amended).
The forms give some relief where the principal’s own design is the cause. GC21 clause 39.3 reduces the contractor’s responsibility to the extent the works are unfit because of the principal’s design. That relief can be removed: where the Contract Information requires it, clauses 39.11 to 39.14 make the contractor check, correct and adopt the principal’s documents as its own, with no reliance on their accuracy.[4]
Notice decides the rest. Under GC21 clause 38, a fault notified at least 21 days before the contractor proposes to use the document is the principal’s to resolve; one not notified in time costs the contractor its delay costs and aborted work.[4] It fails the same way as a late notice for latent conditions: the problem is real, but the letter is late.
The gaps are best handled at tender. Price the ones you can see, carry a provisional sum for work genuinely unknown, and qualify anything the requirements leave open.
Does professional indemnity insurance cover a D&C contractor?
Not automatically, and not for everything a D&C contract asks.
Contract works and public liability policies are built around physical loss, damage and injury. Design error is the territory of professional indemnity, and GC21 lets the principal require a PI policy covering errors in design and documentation, extending to subcontractors and consultants.[4] What a builder normally carries is covered in construction insurance in Australia.
The harder problem is the insurance gap between warranty and policy. PI responds to breach of a professional duty, not to liabilities taken on under contract, and many policies exclude contractually assumed liability.[7] Fitness for purpose requires the designer to be right, not just careful, so a defect with no negligence behind it can be the contractor’s liability and nobody’s insured loss.[7]
The gap runs down the chain too. The standard consultancy form AS 4122-2010 has no fitness for purpose warranty, so a builder that novates consultants on it carries the difference itself. Some insurers will write back fitness for purpose cover by endorsement, though availability depends on the market and is often limited to project-specific policies.[7]
Where each risk sits: construct only, D&C and novated D&C
Risk | Construct only (AS 4000, AS 2124) | Design and construct (AS 4902) | Novated D&C |
|---|---|---|---|
Adequacy of the design | Principal, unless shifted by buildability clauses | Contractor | Contractor, including design done before novation |
Standard of design | Principal’s consultants: reasonable skill and care | Contractor: fitness for purpose | Contractor to principal: fitness for purpose; consultants to contractor: usually skill and care |
Errors in the principal’s documents | Principal; contractor must warn | Contractor, unless the contract gives relief | Contractor, often adopted expressly |
Incomplete brief | Principal; gaps become variations | Contractor; gaps become design development | Contractor; earlier novation, bigger gap |
Principal-directed scope changes | Principal, as a variation | Principal, as a variation | Principal, as a variation |
Claim route for a design defect | Principal against its consultants | Principal against the contractor | Principal against contractor; contractor against novated consultants |
Professional indemnity | Consultants carry it | Contractor needs it or relies on its designers’ cover | Both matter; neither may answer fitness for purpose |
Latent conditions | Set by the latent conditions clause | Set by the latent conditions clause | Set by the latent conditions clause |
The last row is a reminder that not everything shifts. Ground risk follows its own clause in every model, and amendments move it more than the delivery model does.
What good looks like
The builders who make D&C pay never have the design development argument at final account.
Every design revision is tested against a checklist of the requirements, not against the last drawing
A design contingency is priced as its own line, sized to the design stage at novation
Consultant appointments and the novation deed are matched against the head contract warranty
Each change is classified as development or variation when it is issued, with the reason recorded
Design queries run through a formal register, as in a good RFI process, so faults are notified in time
The Australian context
In New South Wales, design risk does not stop at the contract. The Design and Building Practitioners Act 2020 imposes a duty to exercise reasonable care to avoid economic loss caused by defects, owed to each owner of the land and each subsequent owner. Construction work under the Act includes preparing designs for building work and supervising, coordinating or project managing it, so the duty reaches designers as well as builders.[8] Since the High Court’s decision in Pafburn v The Owners Strata Plan No 84674 [2024] HCA 49, that duty cannot be delegated away.
The duty runs to owners, not builders, so it gives a contractor no new claim against the principal’s consultants.[5] A principal that owns the land is itself an owner, though, so it can sue designers and the builder directly under the Act, whatever the delivery model. The ACA also notes that the Act, while not prohibiting novation, greatly discourages early novation on partly complete designs for buildings caught by its design compliance regime: chiefly class 2 apartments and, since 3 July 2023, class 3 and 9c buildings.[6] In residential work, the Home Building Act 1989 (NSW) adds statutory warranties under section 18B, including fitness for a purpose the owner makes known, and section 18G stops a contract excluding them.[3]
The forms are also in transition. AS 4000:2025 was published in June 2025 to modernise the 1997 edition, but AS 4902 is still the 2000 edition, and Standards Australia has said only that it will be revised to align.[2]
This is general information rather than legal advice. The contract you signed, with every amendment, decides who carries the risk.
Where Plexa fits
In Plexa, the Correspondence & Workflows module keeps custom registers for RFIs, submittals, design issues and variations, each item logged with sender, recipient, date, status, due date and attachments. A design revision can be classified as development or variation the week it arrives.
Document Control holds the drawings with version control and revision tracking, and its side-by-side and overlay PDF comparison shows exactly what changed between revision E and revision F of a façade section.
Novated consultant agreements sit in Financial Commitments alongside subcontracts, and the Head Contract module raises claims and variations linked to the subcontractor variations underneath. A design contingency can sit on its own budget cost code. Running those notices, claims and variations day to day is the subject of our upcoming post on head contract administration.
Back in Parramatta, revision F lands in the design issues register with the energy performance requirement it answers to already attached. It is design development, it comes out of the contingency, and everyone at the table can see why. The pergola goes to the developer as a variation the same afternoon.
Frequently asked questions
What is a design and construct contract? A contract where the contractor designs and builds the works, usually for a lump sum, against requirements the principal provides. The main Australian Standard form is AS 4902-2000.[1]
What does D&C contract mean? D&C stands for design and construct. The contractor is responsible for the design as well as the construction, and usually warrants the works fit for their stated purpose.[3]
What is the difference between AS 4902 and AS 4000? AS 4000 is construct only: the principal provides the design and is generally liable for design defects. AS 4902 is design and construct: the contractor completes the design and warrants the works fit for their stated purpose.[1][3]
Is design development a variation? Generally not under D&C. GC21 clause 39.4 says design or design development does not cause a variation. Work needed to deliver the principal’s requirements is development; a change to those requirements is a variation.[4]
Does professional indemnity insurance cover fitness for purpose? Usually not. PI responds to breach of a professional duty, and many policies exclude liability assumed under contract, though some insurers extend cover by endorsement.[7]
Related reading
The broader menu of contract types is in types of construction contracts, and the insurance side of carrying design risk sits in construction insurance in Australia.
If you want to see design revisions, registers and variations working together on a live project, book a 30-minute demo with the Plexa team.
Sources
1. Vincent Young, 2024. Differences in the Design Component Between Australian Standard Contracts and Government Contract GC21. Legal 500. https://www.legal500.com/intelligence/australia/government-public-sector/differences-in-the-design-component-between-australian-standard-contracts-and-government-contract-gc21
2. Standards Australia, 2025. Standards Australia Updates AS 4000:2025 General Conditions of Contract. standards.org.au. https://www.standards.org.au/news/standards-australia-updates-as-4000-2025-general-conditions-of-contract
3. Vincent Young, 2022. Fitness for Purpose Warranties: Contractor Beware. Legal 500 (first published on Mondaq). https://www.legal500.com/intelligence/australia/real-estate-and-construction/fitness-for-purpose-warranties-contractor-beware
4. ACT Government. GC21 (Edition 2) General Conditions of Contract, ACT Modified Version. act.gov.au. https://www.act.gov.au/__data/assets/pdf_file/0011/1942706/GC21-Ed2-General-Conditions-of-Contract.pdf
5. Vincent Young, 2023. Always Presume Design Liability. Legal 500 (first published on Mondaq). https://www.legal500.com/intelligence/australia/real-estate-and-construction/always-presume-design-liability
6. Poulton, W. (Association of Consulting Architects Australia), 2022. Why Novation Is in the Spotlight. aca.org.au. https://aca.org.au/why-novation-is-in-the-spotlight/
7. Burrell, E. (Clyde & Co), 2018. Construction Professionals and Fitness for Purpose Cover: Key Implications for Insurers. Legal 500 (first published on Mondaq). https://www.legal500.com/intelligence/australia/insurance/construction-professionals-and-fitness-for-purpose-cover-key-implications-for-insurers
8. New South Wales. Design and Building Practitioners Act 2020, sections 36 and 37. AustLII. https://classic.austlii.edu.au/au/legis/nsw/consol_act/dabpa2020313/s37.html
Related Articles
The AI Construction Operating System
One platform, one data model, every project. Built in Australia, for the world.
GET THE MOBILE APP
Platform
Solutions
© 2026 Plexa Pro Pty Ltd. ABN 63 668 433 136



